Map Search
Buy
Houses For Sale
Apartments For Sale
Precon & Assignment For Sale
Townhouse For Sale
Open Houses
Rent
Houses For Rent
Apartments For Rent
Townhouse For Rent
Sell
Estimate Your House Value
Blog
Market Trends
Login
Ontario
Similar Sold Properties to 58 Methodist Island, Tay, Port McNicoll | The Canadian Home
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
58 Methodist Island, Tay
Similar Sold Properties
By Distance
255 Poplar Avenue
Date: 16 May 2026
Sold
2 Bedrooms (-1)
2 Bathrooms
0 Garage
Sign in Required
255 Poplar Avenue
Listed:
$
409,900
Sold:
$
417,500
255
Poplar Avenue, Tay, Port McNicoll
2.52 KM
392 William Street
Date: 06 Feb 2026
Sold
3 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms (+1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
392 William Street
Listed:
$
699,900
Sold:
$
599,000
392
William Street, Tay, Victoria Harbour
2.68 KM
655 Fourth Avenue
Date: 30 Apr 2026
Sold
2 Bedrooms (-1)
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
655 Fourth Avenue
Listed:
$
499,900
Sold:
$
490,000
655
Fourth Avenue, Tay, Port McNicoll
2.90 KM
26 Waterside Drive
Date: 08 Jun 2026
Sold
3 Bedrooms
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
26 Waterside Drive
Listed:
$
349,000
Sold:
$
318,000
26
Waterside Drive, Tay, Port McNicoll
3.03 KM
461 Alberta Street
Date: 13 Jun 2026
Sold
3 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
0 Garage
Sign in Required
461 Alberta Street
Listed:
$
598,000
Sold:
$
595,000
461
Alberta Street, Tay, Port McNicoll
3.05 KM
9 Davis Drive
Date: 19 Jan 2026
Sold
2
+ 2
Bedrooms (-1)
2 Bathrooms
0 Garage
Sign in Required
9 Davis Drive
Listed:
$
675,000
Sold:
$
650,000
9
Davis Drive, Tay, Victoria Harbour
3.13 KM
14189 12 Highway
Date: 02 Mar 2026
Sold
2 Bedrooms (-1)
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
14189 12 Highway
Listed:
$
299,999
Sold:
$
251,800
14189
12 Highway, Tay, Rural Tay
5.62 KM
62 Forest Harbour Parkway
Date: 09 Jun 2026
Sold
2 Bedrooms (-1)
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
62 Forest Harbour Parkway
Listed:
$
449,900
Sold:
$
445,000
62
Forest Harbour Parkway, Tay, Rural Tay
5.63 KM
31 Becketts Side Road
Date: 11 May 2026
Sold
3 Bedrooms
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
31 Becketts Side Road
Listed:
$
389,777
Sold:
$
370,000
31
Becketts Side Road, Tay, Rural Tay
5.87 KM
306 Ouida Street
Date: 24 Apr 2026
Sold
2 Bedrooms (-1)
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
306 Ouida Street
Listed:
$
399,900
Sold:
$
410,000
306
Ouida Street, Tay, Waubaushene
5.90 KM
31 Hemlock Avenue
Date: 25 Mar 2026
Sold
4 Bedrooms (+1)
3 Bathrooms (+1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
31 Hemlock Avenue
Listed:
$
888,000
Sold:
$
830,000
31
Hemlock Avenue, Tay, Waubaushene
5.91 KM
328 Percy Street
Date: 25 Mar 2026
Sold
2
+ 1
Bedrooms (-1)
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
328 Percy Street
Listed:
$
399,800
Sold:
$
405,000
328
Percy Street, Tay, Waubaushene
5.93 KM
313 Ouida Street
Date: 22 Jan 2026
Sold
2 Bedrooms (-1)
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
313 Ouida Street
Listed:
$
429,000
Sold:
$
420,000
313
Ouida Street, Tay, Waubaushene
5.96 KM
229 Mountain Avenue
Date: 15 May 2026
Sold
3 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
0 Garage
Sign in Required
229 Mountain Avenue
Listed:
$
474,900
Sold:
$
390,000
229
Mountain Avenue, Tay, Waubaushene
6.27 KM
164 Duck Bay Road
Date: 24 Feb 2026
Sold
2 Bedrooms (-1)
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
164 Duck Bay Road
Listed:
$
749,000
Sold:
$
730,000
164
Duck Bay Road, Tay, Waubaushene
6.36 KM
5855 Vasey Road
Date: 03 Jun 2026
Sold
3 Bedrooms
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
Sign in Required
5855 Vasey Road
Listed:
$
634,900
Sold:
$
630,000
5855
Vasey Road, Tay, Rural Tay
13.33 KM
Showing results
1 — 16 of 16
