• Map Search
    • Houses For Sale
    • Apartments For Sale
    • Precon & Assignment For Sale
    • Townhouse For Sale
    • Open Houses
    • Houses For Rent
    • Apartments For Rent
    • Townhouse For Rent
    • Estimate Your House Value
  • Blog
  • Market Trends
  • Ontario
Address
THE CANADIAN HOME REALTY INC2810 Matheson Blvd E unit 801, MississaugaOntario
Quick links
  • About Us
  • Career
  • Blog
  • Zero Down Payment Program*
  • Our Team
  • FAQ
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Sitemap
get the app
play storeApp Store
download qr code

Copyright © 2026 The Canadian Home Realty Inc.
  • Ontario
  • Tay
  • Port McNicoll
  • 58 Methodist Island
58-methodist-island-tay-ontario-s13227130
58-methodist-island-tay-ontario-s13227130
58-methodist-island-tay-ontario-s13227130
Login/Sign UpTo see all photos
  • For SaleAdded 22 days ago
  • Detached

58 Methodist Island

Tay, Port McNicoll
  • 3 Bedrooms
  • 2 Bathrooms
  • 0 Garage
  • Share
Listed for: $899,900
Estimated Price: $ 883,729
1.8%
Discuss with partner/expertView on Map

Contact an Experienced Real Estate Agent

Upon submitting this form, you acknowledge your agreement to receive marketing phone calls, text messages and emails from The Canadian Home. See more
join-the-canadian-home
JOIN OUR TEAM

Latest listing in Tay

  • 314 Robins Point Road, Tay
  • 1520 Rosemount Road, Tay
  • 46 Forest Harbour Parkway, Tay
  • 2104 Newton Street, Tay
  • 17 Wilcox Road, Tay
  • 81-77 Bass Bay Drive, Tay
  • 41 Hunter Avenue, Tay
  • 208 Cherry Street, Tay
  • 461 Barnes Avenue, Tay
  • 449 Park Street, Tay
  • 49 METHODIST, Tay

Near By Cities

  • Tay Twp
  • Port McNicoll
  • Victoria Harbour
  • Port Severn
  • Waubaushene
  • Midland
  • Penetanguishene
  • Honey Harbour
  • Coldwater
  • Moonstone
  • Tiny Twp

Popular Searches in Tay

  • House for sale in Tay
  • Condo Apartment for sale in Tay
  • Townhouse for sale in Tay
  • Open House in Tay
  • Price dropped properties in Tay
  • Investment properties in Tay
  • Not sold for 30 days in Tay
  • House for rent in Tay
  • Condos for rent in Tay
  • Townhouse for rent in Tay
  • Detached properties in Tay

Room Details of 58 Methodist Island, Tay

FloorBedroomsBathrooms
Ground32
Loading...

Open House

View all upcoming open houses in Tay

No open houses are currently scheduled for this property.

Key Facts About 58 Methodist Island, Tay

  • Tax$3,669 / 2025
  • Property TypeResidential
  • Building TypeDetached
  • Building StyleBungalow
  • Size1100 - 1500 feet²
  • Lot Size77.1 x 220 feet
  • Listing #S13227130
  • Data SourcePROPTX
  • Days on Market21
  • Listed On02/06/2026
  • Updated On15/06/2026
  • Market Demand
    the canadian homethe canadian home

Description

A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighb

Property Details of 58 Methodist Island, Tay

Property

  • Property TypeDetached
  • StyleBungalow
  • Fronting OnE
  • CommunityPort McNicoll
  • MunicipalityTay

Inside

  • Bedrooms3
  • Bathrooms2
  • Kitchen1
  • Rooms8
  • Family RoomsY
  • Central VacN
  • FireplaceN

Utilities

  • WaterOther
  • CoolingNone
  • Heating TypeBaseboard
  • Heating FuelElectric

Building

  • Size1100 - 1500 feet²
  • Architecture StyleBungalow
  • Exterior FeatureBoard & Batten

Parking

  • Garage0
  • Total Parking Places0

Land

  • SewerSeptic
  • Frontage77.1
  • Depth220
  • Lot Size77.1 x 220 feet
  • Lot Size CodeFeet
  • Cross StreetMethodist Island

Our Estimate

Estimated Home Value

$ 883,729

Date of Estimation

02-Jun-2026

School Score

3.3/10

Listings In the Same Street at 58 Methodist Island, Tay

Houses For Sale

View

Houses For Rent

View

Recently Sold

View

Homes listed below the last sold prices in Tay

Loading..

Similar Sold
Similar Properties

Loading..

Loading..

Rooms

Kitchen (5.2X9.34 metre)
Level: Main
Bedroom (4.47X4.06 metre)
Level: Main
Bedroom 2 (3.15X2.94 metre)
Level: Main
Bedroom 3 (3.15X4.32 metre)
Level: Main
Sunroom (3.33X2.77 metre)
Level: Main
Bathroom (3.15X1.24 metre)
Level: Main
Bathroom (2.1X1.14 metre)
Level: Main
Living Room (5.2X5.03 metre)
Level: Main

Expense Breakdown

Monthly Mortgage Payment

$0/monthly

30 Year , 3.99% interest

Cash Expenditure for Home Purchase

$1,000

  • Downpayment
    $0
  • PST on Mortgage Insurance
    $0
  • Land Transfer Tax
    $0
  • Lawyer Fees
    $1,000
  • Title Insurance
    $0

Monthly Expenses After Home Purchase

$569

  • Mortgage Payment
    $0
  • Property Insurance
    $50
  • Property Tax
    $250
  • Phone
    $40
  • Monthly debt payments
    $0
  • Cable
    $60
  • Utilities
    $124
  • Internet
    $45
join-our-teamjoin-our-team

Loading..

MLS® Trusted listing from Toronto Real Estate Board The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos identify professional services rendered by REALTOR® members of CREA to effect the purchase, sale and lease of real estate as part of a cooperative selling system.

Copyright:© The Canadian Home Realty Inc. All rights reserved. The Canadian Home Realty Inc is a registered real estate brokerage.

Affordability Calculator

Find out what home price you can afford.

Are you a first time home buyer ?

Affordability Calculation for a repeat buyer has multiple factors to be considered. Schedule a call with our mortgage specialist to learn more.

About 58 Methodist Island, Tay

Nestled in the picturesque setting of Port McNicoll, this stunning house for sale in Tay at 58 Methodist Island, Tay, is a true gem. Inspired by the serene beauty of Lake Joseph, this detached bungalow offers a unique opportunity to embrace the idyllic lifestyle that Georgian Bay has to offer. With its charming board and batten exterior, this property is not just a house; it's a retreat where you can unwind and enjoy the natural splendour surrounding you.

The house for sale in Tay boasts three spacious bedrooms and two well-appointed bathrooms, making it perfect for families or those looking to entertain guests. Although there is no den, the layout of the home allows for ample space to create your own cosy nooks. With a total of eight rooms, including a welcoming family room, you’ll find plenty of areas to relax and make memories with loved ones. The absence of a central vacuum system and the unfurnished state of the property provides you with a blank canvas to design your dream home.

One of the standout features of this house for sale in Tay is its proximity to the stunning waters of Georgian Bay. Imagine spending your days boating, fishing, and swimming in the crystal-clear waters, or exploring the breathtaking 30,000 islands that dot the landscape. The shallow beachfront is particularly ideal for families, providing a safe and enjoyable environment for children to play. Just a short five-minute boat ride away, you can visit local restaurants and supermarkets, truly embracing the water lifestyle that this area is renowned for.

While the property does not include a pool or a fireplace, the outdoor space is perfect for summer gatherings and barbecues, allowing you to soak in the beauty of your surroundings. The lot measures an impressive 77 by 220 feet, offering plenty of room for outdoor activities or simply enjoying the peaceful atmosphere. Evenings can be spent in the hot tub, where laughter and joy fill the air as children splash about, creating lasting memories.

Inside, the house for sale in Tay has undergone a complete transformation, having been gutted and refurbished to a high standard. The new flooring and modern kitchen, complete with brand-new appliances, ensure that you have everything you need to entertain and enjoy life by the water. The bathrooms have also been beautifully updated, and pot lights throughout the home provide a warm and inviting ambiance.

For those who need to stay connected, high-speed internet is available, making it easy to work remotely while enjoying the tranquillity of your surroundings. You can unwind after a long day by watching your favourite films on the impressive 75-inch big screen TV, turning your living space into a home cinema experience.

As you arrive at 58 Methodist Island, Tay, you’ll be greeted by spectacular views and the friendly waves of your neighbours as you cruise by in your included 21-foot bowrider. This house for sale in Tay is more than just a property; it’s a lifestyle choice that offers the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure.

In summary, if you’re looking for a house for sale in Tay that encapsulates the essence of lakeside living, this is the one for you. With its prime location, modern amenities, and ample space for family and friends, 58 Methodist Island, Tay, is ready to welcome you home. Don’t miss out on this rare opportunity to own a slice of paradise in Port McNicoll!

Port McNicoll, nestled within the charming municipality of Tay, is a picturesque waterfront community that offers a serene escape amidst the natural beauty of Ontario’s landscapes. This quaint locale is situated along the shores of Lake Huron, providing residents with stunning views and a plethora of outdoor activities, from boating and fishing to hiking along scenic trails. The community is steeped in history, with remnants of its rich maritime past evident in its architecture and local attractions. With a close-knit atmosphere, friendly neighbours, and a strong sense of local pride, Port McNicoll presents an inviting environment for those seeking a tranquil lifestyle while remaining connected to the vibrant culture of nearby towns.

Schools in the Neighbourhood

This property is conveniently located near two schools, making it an excellent choice for families with children. The closest option is Tay Shores Public School, situated just 2.1 km away. This elementary school, governed by the Simcoe County District School Board, offers grades from Junior Kindergarten to Grade 8, with a focus on English language instruction. Although it has a school rating of 2.5, it provides a public education option for young learners. Additionally, St. Antoine Daniel Catholic School is located 2.9 km from the property. This school, under the Simcoe Muskoka Catholic District School Board, also serves grades JK to 8 and offers an English language curriculum. However, it currently has a school rating of 0. Both schools cater to the educational needs of children in the area, providing parents with choices for their children's education. The proximity of these institutions adds value to the property, offering families the convenience of accessible schooling options within a short distance.

FAQs About 58 Methodist Island, Tay

How many bathrooms does this property have?

This property features 2 bathroom(s) and 3 bedroom(s).

Does this 3 bedroom property have additional bedrooms or a den?

This Detached property does not have an additional bedroom or a den.

What is the square footage (sqft) of this Detached property?

The total square footage of this Detached 3 bed property in Tay is 1100 - 1500.

How many parking spaces are available with this property?

There are no parking spaces available with this property.

How many cars can be parked in the garage of 58 Methodist Island?

This property does not feature a garage.

What type of garage does this property have?

Information about the garage type is not provided.

Does this property have a basement?

There is no basement in this property.

What type of basement is it?

Information about basement type is not available.

Does this property have a swimming pool?

It is not specified whether this property has a swimming pool.

Does this property have a fireplace?

There is no fireplace in this property.

How many kitchens does this property have?

This property includes 1 kitchen(s).

Is there a maintenance fee associated with this property?

Information about the maintenance fee is not available.

Is this property furnished?

Information about whether this property is furnished is not available.

What type of heating system is in place?

The heating system in place is a Baseboard.

What utilities are available for this property?

Information about utilities is not available.

School Rating for 58 Methodist Island, Tay

XXX

Properties near top rated schools in Tay

Sign Into see near by schools

Listing History

See more recently sold homes in Tay

Real Estate Board require you toSign Into see the full details of this property

Banner Image

Loading....

Similar Properties

See More
10-11-methodist-island-tay-ontario-s13159870
10 & 11 Methodist Island
1
Date: 22 May 2026
For Sale
3 Bedrooms
1 Bathrooms (-1)
0 Garage
10 & 11 Methodist Island
  • $549,900
  • Detached
10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay, Port McNicoll
  • 0.28 KM
  • 46-osborne-street-tay-ontario-s12907660
    46 Osborne Street
    2
    Date: 22 Mar 2026
    For Sale
    2 Bedrooms (-1)
    1 Bathrooms (-1)
    0 Garage
    46 Osborne Street
    • $519,777
    • Detached
    46 Osborne Street, Tay, Victoria Harbour
  • 1.30 KM
  • 148-hoyt-avenue-tay-ontario-s13126260
    148 Hoyt Avenue
    3
    Date: 14 May 2026
    For Sale
    3 Bedrooms
    1 Bathrooms (-1)
    0 Garage
    148 Hoyt Avenue
    • $799,900
    • Detached
    148 Hoyt Avenue, Tay, Victoria Harbour
  • 1.34 KM
  • 91-park-street-tay-ontario-s13460712
    91 Park Street
    4
    Date: 18 Jun 2026
    For Sale
    2 Bedrooms (-1)
    1 Bathrooms (-1)
    0 Garage
    91 Park Street
    • $449,900
    • Detached
    91 Park Street, Tay, Victoria Harbour
  • 1.47 KM
  • 106-william-street-tay-ontario-s12951482
    106 WILLIAM Street
    5
    Date: 02 Apr 2026
    For Sale
    3 Bedrooms
    2 Bathrooms
    0 Garage
    106 WILLIAM Street
    • $469,000
    • Detached
    106 WILLIAM Street, Tay, Victoria Harbour
  • 1.87 KM
  • 153-veterans-lane-tay-ontario-s13106876
    153 Veterans Lane
    6
    Date: 09 May 2026
    For Sale
    2 Bedrooms (-1)
    1 Bathrooms (-1)
    0 Garage
    153 Veterans Lane
    • $439,900
    • Detached
    153 Veterans Lane, Tay, Victoria Harbour
  • 1.89 KM
  • 225-park-street-tay-ontario-s13476298
    225 Park Street
    7
    Date: 22 Jun 2026
    For Sale
    2 Bedrooms (-1)
    1 Bathrooms (-1)
    0 Garage
    225 Park Street
    • $409,900
    • Detached
    225 Park Street, Tay, Victoria Harbour
  • 1.93 KM
  • 119-jephson-street-tay-ontario-s13438104
    119 Jephson Street
    8
    Date: 12 Jun 2026
    For Sale
    4 Bedrooms (+1)
    2 Bathrooms
    0 Garage
    119 Jephson Street
    • $769,900
    • Detached
    119 Jephson Street, Tay, Victoria Harbour
  • 2.10 KM